Is There a Physician Mandate to Connect?

January 2, 2013

The more popular Twitter becomes, the more we hear about the mandate to participate.  Those of us who’ve made the step feel like we’ve discovered something that everyone should do.  We want our friends and coworkers to jump in with us.  In the corporate communications world there’s a shortsighted trend to ‘make CEO’s use Twitter.’  The same pressure can be seen among medical professionals.

The decision to tweet, blog or record should be made on value.  Those of us trained to think in the analog era have a hard time seeing the value of networked knowledge and communication.  The physician’s comfort zone is the silo of the clinic.  Our understanding of professional connection is limited to the doctor’s lounge, hospital hallway or, at best a listserve.  Our understanding of health teaching is limited to the 7 minute face-to-face encounter delivered under the harsh glare of UV lights.

But there are 50 ways to use something like Twitter to make your world, or the world of those around you, a better place.  YouTube’s potential application in health care is limited only by the imagination.  While no one has to use any of these tools, believing that Twitter is only a place to share what you’re eating for breakfast is to live with your head in the sand.

We can’t value what we don’t understand.  And we’ll only understand what something can offer by poking at it and trying it in different ways. The world is increasingly networked.  And when you find the right place to connect, share and create, you’re likely to find value.


{ 8 comments }

Tim McKenna January 2, 2013 at 1:02 pm

Interesting post Dr. Vartabedian,

You make a good point that physicians need to look at using social media on the value that it offers them and/or their patients. Many physicians use social media tools for their original purpose, a personal social network to converse and connect with friends and family, or they use it as a full fledged business/activist outreach into the world. Family Medicine is one area where physicians have taken to use of social media like fish to water.

Facebook, Linkedin, Twitter, Doximity, Youtube, Vimeo, Google Plus, Issuu, Skype, Wordpress, etc….all can be used effectively for a physician with sound planning in mind. This is a shift in thinking for any medical professional…from the CNA to the MD. To use social media beyond personal connections, you have to honestly think of yourself a publisher now, plain and simple.

Now that is a very scary notion for many people (not just physicians, but really anyone) to start thinking that way, let alone learn how to navigate and use all the features that every single application has to offer. I work at the Pennsylvania Academy of Family Physicians as the Graphic Design & Social Media Specialist. We are on the most progressive state academies in the use social media (mostly because I am a total geek about this topic). We saw a niche…the growing adoption of social media use among family doctors, but still others who had to clue what Twitter even was. We created two guides on how to create accounts and use social media channels. Easy, full-color, step-by-step free reference manuals for family physicians (frankly, anyone) on how to setup, post, navigate and create connections on a number of platforms. We posted them on a social publishing site, Issuu, free for anyone to read, bookmark and use as a starting place on how to get going.

We believed that physicians could at least learn the basics of how these applications work, then they can go from there to develop their own voice. Lurking online and taking note on how their peers are using social media is one way we suggest that physicians learn how to think like a publisher.

I believe “mandate” makes the adoption of social media in healthcare sound a little too formal and resistive. There is so many great ideas (and some crappy ones too) that are being shared in the forum of social media, and depending on how much any physician wants to get engaged, they can find their niche online. So “mandate”, sounds a little heavy. I think “invitation” works better. Physicians want to connect with each other, some physicians want to connect with patients in certain ways or others, or some physicians want to talk about health IT, review EHR’s, praise/criticize government policy, or just talk about stuff going on in their communities. We want more physicians to join us online, but just as their are so many different social media platforms, we know their are infinitely more personality types.

You’re absolutely right about once we understand something, we can see the value in it. Physicians make a difference in the lives of their patients everyday, and if social media can be part of that process, great.

I really enjoyed your post. I think it will give physicians something to think about as we continue to become an ever more interconnected population.

- Tim McKenna

http://issuu.com/pafppublications

DrV January 2, 2013 at 5:29 pm

Thanks for your comments, Tim. Your views and work are way ahead of the curve (wasn’t Mike Sevilla working with you on that?).

Regarding the mandate, I’m with you. I so often hear the hard push for docs to use Tw. They’ve gotta come to it on their own but they’ve gotta maintain a new open attitude regarding these tools. Poking and flirting are critical.

Greg Matthews January 2, 2013 at 3:52 pm

I agree that twitter is one of those things that definitely isn’t for everyone … but I also agree that ignorance isn’t necessarily bliss! I’m a big fan of the “lurk and learn first” school of thinking … it’s so easy to tune into a few folks on twitter for 30 seconds a day, just to see if there’s anything interesting going on. If not, you move on to the next thing … but you never know what you might find.

And Tim’s approach (see comment above) is amazing – would love to see the materials he’s put together!

DrV January 2, 2013 at 5:32 pm

Yup. I recommend that folks pick out a few people in their field that are doing it right and follow them for a while, or lurk as you suggested. You can only learn about the power of these tools by seeing how other folks use them. Lots of great success stories out there to learn from.

Carolyn Thomas January 2, 2013 at 6:17 pm

Thanks for this, Dr. V – I love Greg’s “lurk and learn” advice, and Tim’s resources sound like such a good place to start.

Also useful for those who might like a more personal focus would be to access professional resources like those organized by Dr. Faris Timimi, Medical Director at Mayo Clinic’s Center for Social Media – such as their upcoming 2-day Social Media Residency programs – here’s more on the 2013 scheduled dates: http://socialmedia.mayoclinic.org/2012/12/04/first-four-social-media-residency-dates-announced-for-2013/

I worked in the public relations field for over 30 years, many of those years spent doing media training for corporate execs. Without exception, as you might expect, I worked with skilled, educated, very smart people at the top of their game. But stick a reporter’s microphone in their face and there was no guarantee that even somebody who was skilled, educated, and very smart at their job would also be innately qualified to work effectively with the media. Same with social media – and just like in media relations, many feel pressured to get involved whether or not they should.

Both those CEOs and physicians needs to learn, as the Mayo Social Media Residency programs teach, the basic components of an appropriate social media strategy before jumping in with both feet. It’s too important an endeavor to leave this to chance.

Mark Harmel January 3, 2013 at 6:19 pm

In this video Berwick say that those that speak are heard. He advises speaking up. “Quality Leaders Need to Step UpBy Donald Berwick, M.D.” http://bit.ly/VBajWH

Karen Hoyt January 3, 2013 at 9:04 pm

As a patient/consumer, I “lurked and learned” about my disease from well informed medical experts. The anecdotal information from others was beneficial also. That is a 2 edged sword if misinformation is published. Pf course my doctor was always the final authority.
For example, I had the ability to research tests, lab values, and pharmaceutical information saving time for everyone. From my perspective, social networking and the global information highway is a great tool for those in the medical profession as well as the patient.

Karen Hoyt January 3, 2013 at 9:09 pm

P.S. I found this article on my twitter account and liked it on facebook!

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: